Scouting 101: NFL Quarterback Rankings Updated
by Matt Miller
We blame Brett Favre for making us re-do our rankings. Here is the most updated list, with Mr. Favre returning to the rankings.
NES Rank Num Player Profile Team NES Grade
1 12 Brady, Tom NE (10)
2 18 Manning, Peyton IND (10)
3 9 Brees, Drew NO (9)
4 7 Roethlisberger, Ben PIT (9)
5 8 Hasselbeck, Matt SEA (9)
6 9 Romo, Tony DAL (9)
7 9 Palmer, Carson CIN (9)
8 5 McNabb, Donovan PHI (8)
9 9 Garrard, David JAC (8)
10 4 Favre, Brett NYJ (8)
11 10 Manning, Eli NYG (8)
12 10 Bulger, Marc STL (8)
13 3 Anderson, Derek CLE (8)
14 17 Rivers, Philip SD (8)
15 17 Campbell, Jason WAS (7)
16 6 Cutler, Jay DEN (7)
17 7 Garcia, Jeff TB (7)
18 17 Delhomme, Jake CAR (7)
19 10 Pennington, Chad MIA (7)
20 7 Leinart, Matt ARI (7)
21 8 Schaub, Matt HOU (7)
22 12 Rodgers, Aaron GB (7)
23 10 Young, Vince TEN (7)
24 5 Edwards, Trent BUF (6)
25 8 Kitna, Jon DET (6)
26 7 Boller, Kyle BAL (6)
27 10 Quinn, Brady CLE (6)
28 7 Jackson, Tarvaris MIN (6)
29 2 Russell, JaMarcus OAK (6)
30 2 Simms, Chris TB (6)
31 7 Volek, Billy SD (6)
32 7 Losman, J.P. BUF (6)
33 2 Ryan, Matt ATL (6)
34 13 Warner, Kurt ARI (6)
35 5 Stanton, Drew DET (6)
36 3 Moore, Matt CAR (6)
37 18 Orton, Kyle CHI (6)
38 18 Rosenfels, Sage HOU (6)
39 5 Gray, Quinn IND (6)
40 11 Clemens, Kellen NYJ (6)
41 4 McCown, Josh MIA (6)
42 8 Redman, Chris ATL (6)
43 8 Grossman, Rex CHI (6)
44 8 Carr, David NYG (6)
45 16 Cassel, Matt NE (5)
46 11 Brohm, Brian GB (5)
47 5 Flacco, Joe BAL (5)
48 7 Henne, Chad MIA (5)
49 11 Smith, Alex SF (5)
50 4 Kolb, Kevin PHI (5)
51 6 Whitehurst, Charlie SD (5)
52 7 Gutierrez, Matt NE (5)
53 13 Harrington, Joey ATL (5)
54 9 Bollinger, Brooks MIN (5)
55 5 Collins, Kerry TEN (5)
56 17 Lemon, Cleo JAC (5)
57 13 Hill, Shaun SF (5)
58 10 Smith, Troy BAL (5)
59 15 Wallace, Seneca SEA (5)
60 16 Batch, Charlie PIT (5)
61 12 Croyle, Brodie KC (5)
62 8 Griese, Brian TB (5)
63 11 Ramsey, Patrick DEN (5)
64 11 Brunell, Mark NO (5)
65 15 Collins, Todd WAS (5)
66 5 Frye, Charlie SEA (5)
67 12 Green, Trent STL (5)
68 11 Huard, Damon KC (5)
69 12 McCown, Luke TB (5)
70 7 Vick, Michael ATL (5)
71 16 Walter, Andrew OAK (5)
72 14 O’Sullivan, J.T. SF (4)
73 6 Orlovsky, Dan DET (4)
74 5 Ratliff, Brett NYJ (4)
75 4 Thigpen, Tyler KC (4)
76 9 Ainge, Erik NYJ (4)
77 2 Dixon, Dennis PIT (4)
78 14 Feeley, A.J. PHI (4)
79 12 Frerotte, Gus MIN (4)
80 14 Johnson, Brad DAL (4)
81 12 Sorgi, Jim IND (4)
82 3 Woodson, Andre NYG (4)
83 4 Booty, John David MIN (4)
84 8 Ricard, Lester CAR (4)
85 3 Shockley, D.J. ATL (4)
86 2 Wright, Anthony NYG (4)
87 4 Bouman, Todd JAC (4)
88 8 Gradkowski, Bruce STL (4)
89 13 Lorenzen, Jared IND (4)
90 8 Tuiasosopo, Marques OAK (4)
91 9 Beck, John MIA (4)
92 14 Basanez, Brett CAR (3)
93 5 Brennan, Colt WAS (3)
94 10 Flynn, Matt GB (3)
95 5 O’Connell, Kevin NE (3)
96 13 Berlin, Brock STL (3)
97 11 Dorsey, Ken CLE (3)
98 3 Rowe, Jeff CIN (3)
99 5 Palmer, Jordan CIN (3)
100 8 Bramlet, Casey SD (3)
101 11 Johnson, Josh TB (3)
102 11 Fitzpatrick, Ryan CIN (3)
103 10 Brink, Alex HOU (3)
104 7 Boyd, Shane HOU (3)
105 4 Hackney, Darrell DEN (3)
106 10 Terrell, Jeff DAL (3)
107 10 Hamdan, Gibran BUF (3)
108 4 Bartel, Richard DAL (2)
109 2 St. Pierre, Brian ARI (2)
110 3 Wright, Kyle SF (2)
111 16 Baker, Matt BUF (2)
112 3 Martin, Ingle TEN (2)
113 12 Morelli, Anthony ARI (2)
114 8 Potts, Mike PIT (2)
115 3 Palko, Tyler NO (1)
116 12 Hanie, Caleb CHI (1)
117 7 Otis, Jeff OAK (1)
118 9 Bell, Dalton SEA (1)
119 2 Devine, Derek WAS (1)